By Emma Cueto
Law360 (July 18, 2025, 3:21 PM EDT) — California firm Keesal Young & Logan’s suit against Stradley Ronon Stevens & Young LLP for allegedly unfairly poaching a group of its attorneys is not on firm footing, recruiters and consultants say, but still speaks to the importance of trying to leave a firm on good terms when moving jobs.
In a complaint filed Monday in California state court, Keesal Young alleged that Stradley Ronon induced five partners who left to form Stradley Ronon’s first California office in 2024 to violate the terms of its partnership agreement, among other allegations.
Industry observers said that some of the alleged conduct outlined in the complaint, such as leaving with only a few days notice and recruiting associates before leaving the firm, which Keesal Young said are both violations of the partnership agreement, were ethically questionable if true; however, other things detailed in the complaint, such as sharing client names, moving to a nearby office and speaking with a firm over the course of months are normal parts of lateral recruiting.
Yet the fact that the dispute has boiled over into litigation is a good reminder to attorneys to try to leave firms on good terms if possible.
“So much of a lawyer’s business is referred,” said New York-based consultant and recruiter Chris Batz. “I’ve seen plenty of candidates that leave and don’t burn bridges and keep referral relationships at the former firm. There are just better ways to leave a law firm than burning bridges.”
Stradley Ronon, which is based in Pennsylvania, recruited five partners and five associates from Keesal Young to launch its first West Coast office in April 2024. According to the complaint filed by Keesal Young, the partners at the firm began talking to Stradley Ronon eight months earlier, communicating using work phones.
The complaint objects to various aspects of the partners’ behavior during this time, including sharing client names and compensation information, using firm computer systems to set up Zoom meetings with Stradley Ronon, not giving Keesal Young a heads up before the firm signed a new lease and speaking with representatives from Stradley Ronon numerous times during the process.
After announcing their departure, the partners gave just four days’ notice, according to the complaint, instead of the 30 required by the partnership agreement. The complaint also details the number of communications over work devices between the departing partners and the associates who would eventually join them, alleging these calls were attempts to recruit the associates, though specific details of the subject matter are not included.
After leaving, the complaint says, the 10 attorneys moved to an office “down the street,” allegedly violating the partnership agreement’s noncompete provisions, and their loss caused Keesal Young “significant monetary harm,” forcing it to spend time recruiting and training new personnel, saddling it with a more expensive lease than it otherwise would have chosen, and taking away an estimated $2.5 million in profit per year.
Stradley Ronon said in a statement Tuesday that the claims in the suit were false. “It is unfortunate Keesal, Young & Logan is coming after another law firm for what is a common, everyday occurrence in our industry,” it said.
Keesal Young did not respond to a request for comment.
Industry experts took a mostly dim view of the suit.
“Claims like conspiracy, misappropriation of trade secrets — client names and client information are not proprietary information,” said California legal recruiter Larry Watanabe. “Firms have to run conflict checks. It happens every day. This is how the lateral market works.”
Legal ethics practitioner John Steele, who is based in Palo Alto and has counseled attorneys leaving firms, noted that it is difficult in California for even a nonlawyer to enforce a noncompete agreement, and this is doubly true for attorneys, given the principle that clients must be allowed to choose their own legal counsel.
“I am somewhat puzzled by the apparent claim that Keesal obtained an enforceable promise not to compete,” he said.
It is true that partners cannot recruit other firm personnel before their notice period is over, observers said, and it’s usually best to follow the notice requirements spelled out in a partnership agreement. As recruiter Batz put it, “If you signed a partnership agreement that says there’s a 30-day period for notice, you should abide by that.”
However, he noted, other things detailed in the complaint, such as discussions with the recruiting firm going on for months, are realities of the lateral market.
Watanabe put it even more bluntly: “This is recruiting 101,” he said, adding, “This implies [to recruiters] you can’t run a lateral process there.”
Regardless of how the case unfolds, however, recruiters said that it’s a good reminder for attorneys to try not to burn bridges when moving firms. Part of that is abiding by best practices, such as following the requirements in the partnership agreement.
“I always just advise people to read their partnership agreement; it’s not uncommon to hear they haven’t read it since they signed it 20 years ago,” Watanabe said.
Batz and Watanabe both said they usually refer lateral candidates to ethics counsel as well, to make sure everything is being done by the book.
It’s also important attorneys try not to alienate people at their old firm on a personal level.
“There’s an accepted understanding [when people are leaving] that some partners might violate some provision of an agreement, but as long as the partners aren’t belligerent, aren’t flagrant, aren’t doing something obviously stupid on the way out, they usually can get away with it,” Batz said.
That kind of grace is more likely to be given when attorneys are well liked and have developed positive relationships with their co-workers already, he added.
“Partners outgrow platforms, clients outgrow platforms; it often requires people to move on,” he said. “[I tell people to] celebrate the opportunities and relationships you had at the firm and hold your head up high.”
–Editing by Alex Hubbard.